What Putin wants in Ukraine

You’re speechmaking an excerpt from the Today’s WorldView newsletter. Sign up to get the rest, including quality from astir the globe, absorbing ideas and opinions to cognize sent to your inbox each weekday.

On the fertile plains of Ukraine, the resurgent echoes of a Cold War with Russia is successful information of becoming a slayer frost. Washington is sounding the alarm implicit Russian President Vladimir Putin’s troops massed astatine the border, and a imaginable onslaught against the western-gazing authorities successful Kyiv. As the stakes soar to the hazard of warfare successful Europe, 1 question is astatine the bosom of the crisis: What does Putin truly want?

The possibilities are myriad and — particularly for the hopes of an independent, thriving and antiauthoritarian Ukraine — scope from atrocious to worse. To unit the West into wide information concessions successful Eastern Europe? To efficaciously destruct immoderate aboriginal way to NATO membership, and semipermanent security, for what remains of Ukraine? To formalize the grip of Russian-backed separatists successful Ukraine’s Donbas region, invaded by Moscow’s “little greenish men” successful 2014 and stuck successful a near-constant authorities of equipped struggle ever since? Or is Putin truly intent connected flying the Russian emblem implicit Kyiv’s Maidan Square to implicit his imaginativeness of Ukraine arsenic a cardinal portion of the Russian state?

Long-brewing concerns implicit Russian designs successful Ukraine, which had calmed pursuing a akin situation past spring, person leaped backmost into the nationalist oculus successful caller weeks arsenic U.S. officials warned that quality signaled the increasing hazard of a Russian invasion. President Biden has ruled retired 1 halfway Putin request — a gurantee that Ukraine volition ne'er articulation the NATO alliance. But Putin has already succeeded successful astatine slightest 1 thing: making the West wage attention.

In their astir caller call, my colleagues reported, Putin countered that immoderate caller sanctions from the Ukraine situation would trigger “a implicit rupture of relations” betwixt Moscow and Washington.

The intervention of Russian troops successful Kazakhstan connected the petition of its pro-Kremlin authorities pursuing the eruption of wide protests whitethorn yet power the Kremlin’s subject calculus oregon timing successful Ukraine. On the backmost of the convulsive quashing of dissent successful Belarus, the uprising successful Kazakhstan underscores the challenges facing Russia successful maintaining is sphere of influence.

But the situation present is to crippled Putin’s bigger strategy successful Ukraine.

In a captivating portion successful the Atlantic, Anne Applebaum writes of 2 schools of thought successful Kyiv. “The skeptical schoolhouse fundamentally thinks this full concern mightiness beryllium a immense bluff: The Russians person deliberately acceptable retired to ‘scare the Americans,’ ” she said, “in bid to make unit connected Ukraine to alteration its constitution arsenic the Russians would like, oregon to enactment Putin astatine the halfway of planetary attention, oregon to reestablish a Russian sphere of power wrong aged Soviet borders.”

For them, Putin’s extremity seems to person “chalked up immoderate wins” by focusing the attraction of the White House and NATO not connected the Ukraine situation per se, but connected Russia’s attempts to unit the West to prosecute it implicit trumped-up claims of Western aggression.

Back successful Kyiv, Applebaum said the pessimists fearfulness this: “If Putin believes that Ukraine indispensable beryllium destroyed sooner oregon later; if helium believes that humanities wrongs indispensable beryllium righted; adjacent if helium conscionable wants to summation backmost immoderate of the popularity helium has mislaid to covid, corruption, and a mediocre economy, past helium mightiness person reasons to deliberation that this is simply a bully infinitesimal to bash it.”

The United States is simply a house divided. The E.U. is pandemic-weary and distracted. What amended infinitesimal could Putin get?

A amended appraisal of Russian motives and goals could beryllium the astir utile takeaway from the high-stakes meetings successful Europe adjacent week.

“I deliberation Putin wants a mates of things retired of the situation helium has created, 1 of which is simply a colony of the [conflict successful eastbound Ukraine] connected Russian terms, with dense autonomy for the Donbas region,” Defense Priorities Policy Director Benjamin H. Friedman told Today’s WorldView this week. “And secondly, helium wants the U.S. to instrumentality the pb of saying nary NATO successful Ukraine, and nary Ukraine successful NATO.”

Andrew Lohsen, a Russia adept astatine the Center for Strategic and International Studies, told maine helium expects the talks to commencement disconnected beardown successful the bilateral with the Russians and Americans, earlier losing steam erstwhile the forum shifts to NATO. Moscow would beryllium making the constituent that it feels Washington is the decider, and thus, wants to woody straight with the White House.

The question is not lone whether Biden whitethorn yet budge connected immoderate benignant of pledge to Putin connected Ukraine, but however overmuch Washington is consenting to sermon a broader revamp of the information paradigm successful Europe. Putin, though, has generated truthful overmuch buzz implicit the situation astatine home that helium whitethorn person gone excessively acold to simply backmost down now. If helium gets nary concessions, helium has assorted options. They could see rocket strikes, cyberattacks, a broader involution successful Donbas or, arsenic immoderate fear, a afloat connected invasion.

“Russia needs to travel retired of this situation with immoderate benignant of victory; it needs immoderate benignant of concession from the U.S. oregon NATO,” Lohsen told me. “Limiting subject deployments adjacent Russian borders could beryllium sufficient, but I’m not definite if that’s going to beryllium enough. This could precise good beryllium a pretext” for aggression.

But Putin has besides succeeded successful thing other too: Raising the terms for Western enactment successful Ukraine. Even if Russian boots ne'er march connected Kyiv, the continuing menace of an penetration could yet compel Washington and the E.U. to tread much lightly there, and concede a measurement of Russian influence, whether the Ukrainians similar it oregon not.

“The speech has shifted from however to resoluteness this situation successful Ukraine to however we forestall a warfare successful Europe,” Lohsen told me. “I deliberation the presumption are overmuch broader now, and I deliberation immoderate happens, Ukraine volition extremity up a worse presumption than before.”